Email For My Friend Mark Fisher

by Mark Fisher

Since yours truly is busy with New Dad Life, we’ve got a guest email from my pal John Franklin of Gym Lead Machine.

Fun fact: John has been a pal of mine and Keeler’s for many years. Before his current business, John ran several highly successful Crossfit gyms in the NYC area. So this is a guy who not only knows his stuff through working with gyms all over the world, but has walked his walk in the hyper-competitive world of NYC fitness.

He’s one of the savviest business brains I’ve met in the entire industry. And in today’s guest email, he’s dropping the goods on effective websites for gyms.



The Elements of a Really, Really, Really Ridiculously Good Looking Gym Website

At Gym Lead Machine, we’ve built over 1,000 gym websites in the last two years. Here’s my quick and dirty guide for building a homepage that converts.

Let’s break the homepage into two sections: above the fold and below the fold.

Above the fold

The section above the fold is what a user sees before scrolling. It’s their first impression of your site, and first impressions are everything. 

We spend thousands of dollars every year conducting user research to optimize this prime real estate. 

We conduct thousands of “five-second tests.” 

A five-second test is where we show users a site for 5 seconds and then ask them a series of questions. 

If the site is good, a user should be able to answer: 

  1. What the business does.
  2. Whom the business serves. 
  3. Where the business is located. 
  4. Is the business trustworthy?
  5. Is the business professional?


Let’s look at a few real-life examples. Spend five seconds looking at each of these headers. 

Example 1

Example 2

Now ask yourself: 

Which gym makes a better first impression?

  • Which gym has better service?
  • Which gym costs more? 
  • Where is each gym located?
  • How do you get started? 

We haven’t scrolled yet, but we’ve already made hundreds of little judgments about each business. 

TLDR: If your header section isn’t clear, it’s costing you thousands of dollars in lost revenue.

Below the fold

This is the part of the site that’s visible after scrolling. 

A good “below the fold” section includes: 

Clear directions on how to start

  • A brief description of your core services
  • Social proof. 
  • A secondary call to action

Let’s break down each one.

Clear Directions on How to Start

Joining a gym is scary. The first section below the fold should address this common fear. Show prospects that you understand what they’re going through, and tell them how to get started. 

Unclear instructions cause sales friction which lowers conversion rates.

Let’s compare two “getting started” sections: 

Example 1

Example 2

Now think like a potential prospect. 

  • Which business explains how to start? 
  • Which business would you rather buy from? 
  • Which business will do a better job at helping you reach your goals? 

Don’t shoot yourself in the foot. Make it easy for people to conduct business with you. 

Brief Description of Your Core Services

Here is where you showcase what you do best. Don’t overdo it. Let’s compare two restaurants to illustrate the point. 

Which restaurant would you rather eat at: 

Restaurant 1: “The World’s Best Cheeseburgers”

Restaurant 2: “The World’s Best Cheeseburgers, Tacos, and Sushi” 

If you’re from earth, the answer is number 1. Why is that? 

You’re likely skeptical of any restaurant that claims to be the best at three different cuisines. The same is true in fitness. No one will believe you if you claim to be the best at personal training, group training, nutrition coaching, and kids trampoline classes.

Social Proof 

Social proof is crucial for gyms. Convey that you’re the place that gets people results, and you’ll be able to charge premium prices. 

No one does this better than Ultimate Performance; they have so much social proof on their site.

At an absolute minimum, showcase three client results on your homepage. If you don’t have before & after photos, use Google reviews, written testimonials, or Facebook posts. 

Secondary Call to Action

Not everyone that visits your site will be ready to buy. A lead magnet lets you keep up with prospects that aren’t ready to book a consultation. You don’t need to get too fancy here; recipes, at-home workouts, and shopping guides work well. 


Follow these simple steps, and you’ll be ahead of 90% of gym owners. If your site needs a touch up, feel free to use these examples as a guide (but don’t copy them word-for-word, our lawyers don’t like that.) 

Or hire us to do it for you. 

Sites are $19 a week & if you’re in the Unicorn Society you get 2 months free with a 1-year commitment.


Smart guy, eh? 🙂



Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

A (Counter-Intuitive) Facilities Tip…

Here’s a quickie pro–tip to best nurture your facility. When making improvements, don’t do everything all at once. If you’re anything like me, you like to get THINGS DONE. FAST. (I have many lovely qualities. Patience is not among them.) So when I’m thinking about...

“It Worked So Well, I Stopped Doing It!”

First up, want to give you a gentle reminder, you have until tomorrow to sign up for my upcoming time management workshop and save $200. I’ll be hosting it over Zoom on January 7th from 10am est to 5pm est. Although live attendance is strongly encouraged, we will be...

Who We Are

We’re just a few days away from the closing of the Early Bird window for the Unicorn Society’s 2023 enrollment… So I want to shamelessly talk about the humans who provide the BFU coaching magic.  If you’re looking for support in growing your training gym, you have one...

Exactly What I Track (Personal, Financial, Business)

First off, reminder: this is one of your only chances of the year to join a crew of some of the fitness industry’s most successful gyms AND get personal coaching from Michael Keeler, Pete Dupuis, Ben “the Secret Weapon” Pickard, and yours truly.  To learn more about...

Top Lessons From A Unicorn Society Member Turned COO

Today we have a guest post from BFU coach (and now COO!), Ben “The Secret Weapon” Pickard.  Ben was a client for many years. Since we just opened up enrollment for the 2023 Unicorn Society, I’ve asked him to share a bit about his experience. He also includes one super...

3 Takeaways From My #1 Tool [I Legit Cried To My Wife]

I had a pretty intense experience recently… For the first time in years –– possibly since I wrote them –– I went into old journals and reviewed my planned 5-year goals from ten years ago. The years described were 2017- 2020 (written in 2012-2015). As I flipped through...